We developed a model of chorioamnionitis to simulate fetal exposure to maternal inflammation (FEMI) without complications of live organisms to examine the effects of FEMI on development of the offspring’s intestinal tract. This allows for study of mechanistic causes for development of intestinal injury following chorioamnionitis.
Chorioamnionitis is a common precipitant of preterm birth and is associated with many of the morbidities of prematurity, including necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC). However, a mechanistic link between these two conditions remains yet to be discovered. We have adopted a murine model of chorioamnionitis involving lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-induced fetal exposure to maternal inflammation (FEMI). This model of FEMI induces a sterile maternal, placental, and fetal inflammatory cascade, which is also present in many cases of clinical chorioamnionitis. Although models exist that utilize live bacteria and more accurately mimic the pathophysiology of an ascending infection resulting in chorioamnionitis, these methods may cause indirect effects on development of the immature intestinal tract and the associated developing microbiome. Using this protocol, we have demonstrated that LPS-induced FEMI results in a dose-dependent increase in pregnancy loss and preterm birth, as well as disruption of normal intestinal development in offspring. Further, we have demonstrated that FEMI significantly increases intestinal injury and serum cytokines in offspring, while simultaneously decreasing goblet and Paneth cells, both of which provide a first line of innate immunity against intestinal inflammation. Although a similar model of LPS-induced FEMI has been used to model the association between chorioamnionitis and subsequent abnormalities of the central nervous system, to our knowledge, this protocol is the first to attempt to elucidate a mechanistic link between chorioamnionitis and later perturbations in intestinal development as a potential link between chorioamnionitis and NEC.
The chorionic membranes play an integral role in mammalian pregnancy. They include the chorion and amnion, which serve multiple functions. They surround and protect the fetus, facilitate paracrine signaling between the maternal and fetal compartments1, and create local feedback loops within the chorionic membranes, which may be involved in initiating parturition1. Current understanding of the membranes indicates that the amnion provides structural barrier function, and the chorion provides an immunological buffer primarily to protect the developing fetus from the maternal immune system2. Inflammation of these membranes is known as chorioamnionitis. Historically, the diagnosis of clinical chorioamnionitis was made following the presence of maternal fever plus one or more fetal or maternal clinical findings3,4. However, while this definition is clinically useful, its lack of precision has made chorioamnionitis research challenging. In 2015, in an attempt to clarify the diagnosis, an expert panel workshop by the Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute for Child Health and Human Development defined chorioamnionitis as intrauterine inflammation, or infection, or both (triple I)3. This clarification is important because while microbial induced infection is an important cause of uterine/amniotic inflammation, it occurs less commonly than sterile uterine/amniotic inflammation5,6,7. Overall, chorioamnionitis remains a significant public health problem, as it is seen in 2‒4% of term deliveries and 25‒30% of preterm deliveries8,9.
Chorioamnionitis can have significant effects on the fetus and neonate. It has been well documented in the literature that chorioamnionitis is associated with increased risk of many of the morbidities of prematurity, including bronchopulmonary dysplasia10, cerebral white matter injury11, intraventricular hemorrhage12, retinopathy of prematurity13, and both suspected and confirmed early onset neonatal sepsis14,15. As we are interested in injury and repair mechanisms of the immature intestinal tract, it is important to note that chorioamnionitis is also associated with later development of necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC)15,16. NEC is a devastating gastrointestinal disease of preterm infants that results in a dysregulated host response to inflammation and subsequent intestinal necrosis17. Each year, NEC affects over 4000 infants in the United States, and up to one third of these infants die from the disease18. The pathogenesis of NEC likely involves a combination of intestinal immaturity, dysregulation of the immature immune system, intestinal inflammation, and bacterial translocation19, culminating in a final common pathway of intestinal necrosis. Importantly, the onset of NEC often occurs weeks after birth and potential exposure to chorioamnionitis, making the mechanistic link between chorioamnionitis and subsequent development of NEC unclear20. One potential mechanism by which chorioamnionitis may contribute to the pathophysiology of NEC is through upregulation of the maternal immune system, subsequently producing a strong fetal inflammatory response which may disrupt normal fetal developmental patterns21,22,23.
Multiple mammalian models of chorioamnionitis exist in rodents and sheep24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32. However, few data exist concerning the development of the intestinal tract beyond the initial newborn period following chorioamnionitis-induced fetal exposure to maternal inflammation (FEMI). In order to explore the relationship between FEMI and subsequent development of injury of the immature intestinal tract, we have adapted the lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-induced FEMI model. Lipopolysaccharides are a major component of the extracellular surface on gram negative bacteria and are a potent stimulant of the innate immune system of multiple eukaryotic species, including humans33. Maternal LPS injection results in a sterile inflammatory cascade without the confounding effects of live bacteria, and it is a well-established model for induction of preterm birth34, as well as a model of acute chorioamnionitis and the fetal inflammatory response syndrome (FIRS), which is the most severe form of chorioamnionitis24,35. It has also been shown to induce both cerebral white and gray matter injury in a sheep model36 and a murine model37,38,39,40. However, to our knowledge, we are the first to use this model of chorioamnionitis and FEMI to investigate its effects on the development of the gastrointestinal tract past birth, as well as to investigate a possible mechanistic link between chorioamnionitis and later development of NEC41,42.
All animal procedures were approved by the University of Iowa Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (Protocol #8041401). All animals were housed in an Association for Assessment and Accreditation of Laboratory Animal Care (AALAC) approved vivarium at the University of Iowa. All mice were wild type strain C57Bl/6J.
1. Establishment of FEMI in pregnant mice
2. Delivery and care of offspring, and intestinal harvesting
3. Intestinal injury scoring
4. Quantification of Paneth and goblet cells
Exposure to FEMI on embryonic day 15 leads to a dose-dependent loss of pregnancy and a dose dependent rate of preterm labor (Figure 1)42. For the experiments, we chose to use an LPS dose of 100 µg/kg to minimize pregnancy loss and prematurity (50% loss between both prematurity and intrauterine fetal demise) while exposing the fetuses to a significant inflammatory insult.
Using this approach, we next examined the effects of FEMI on subsequent injury of the offspring. Using a 3-point histologic scale to measure generalized intestinal injury, we found significant injury at birth (P0) and at adulthood (P56 or 8 weeks of life) (Figure 2). It is important to note that this injury occurred in the absence of any additional stimuli to the animals other than FEMI, suggesting that FEMI alone disrupts the normal homeostasis of the newborn murine intestinal tract. As the mouse is born with a relatively immature intestine that continues to develop during the first 4 weeks of life47,48, this is relevant to preterm infants who also have immature intestinal tracts.
To further understand the effect of FEMI on both the normal development of the intestinal epithelium and on the defense mechanisms of the immature intestinal tract, we quantified the number of mucin-producing goblet cells and antimicrobial peptide-producing Paneth cells in the distal third of the small intestinal tract which is similar to the human ileum. We found that FEMI disrupted the normal composition of the intestinal epithelium by inducing loss of both goblet cells and Paneth cells compared to animals without FEMI (Figure 3).
To investigate the effects of FEMI on the neonatal inflammatory response, using ELISA with electrochemiluminescence, we quantified a variety of serum inflammatory markers, which included IL-1β, IL-10, KC-GRO (the murine equivalent of IL-8), and IL-6, from serum of pups with and without FEMI (Figure 4). We found that FEMI significantly increased the inflammatory cascade for all cytokines at P0. The inflammatory cascade at later ages (P7‒P56) differed based on timepoint and cytokine. Most interestingly, for IL-6, there were similar levels at P7‒P28 in the FEMI and sham groups, but despite no secondary intervention, there were significantly higher levels in the FEMI group at P56. This is especially important as we have demonstrated that IL-6 is a critical cytokine for the development of postnatal intestinal injury in the FEMI model.
Figure 1: Effect of FEMI dose on pregnancy outcomes. Survival of pregnancy litters is dose dependent with higher doses causing higher rates of pregnancy loss (A) and higher rates of premature birth (B). Figure is adapted with permission from Fricke et al42. FEMI using an LPS dose of 100 µg/kg creates a 50% survival for pups by one week of life. Each data point is representative of an n > 8 pregnancies and at least three individual experiments. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Effect of FEMI on distal small intestinal injury patterns over time. Intestinal samples were harvested at birth, 1 week of life, 2 weeks of life, and 8 weeks of life from mice exposed to FEMI (100 µg/kg of LPS) or sham control. Samples were scored using a 3-point injury scale by blinded investigators42,43. FEMI alone with no further insult induced significant amount of injury at birth, 1 week of life, and at 8 weeks of life. Figure has been adapted with permission from Fricke et al.42. Each data point is representative of an n > 10 pups and at least three individual experiments from at least 3 pregnant dams. Mann-Whitney non-parametric T-testing was used to compare intestinal injury scores at each timepoint. The asterisk indicates p < 0.05. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: FEMI induces alterations of normal goblet and Paneth cell quantities in the small intestine during development. Intestinal samples were harvested at birth, 1, 2, 4, and 8 weeks of life from mice exposed to FEMI (100 µg/kg LPS) or sham control. Samples were stained with Alcian blue/Periodic Acid Schiff stain to detect both goblet and Paneth cells and these were quantified by a blinded investigator. Both goblet cells and Paneth cells from animals with FEMI showed either a trend or a significant decrease compared to sham controls at all ages. Figure adapted with permission from Elgin et al.41. Each data point is representative of an n > 10 pups and at least three individual experiments. Error bars represent standard error of the mean. Student T-testing was used to compare quantities of goblet and Paneth cells at each time point. The asterisk indicates p < 0.05. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 4: FEMI induces a global neonatal inflammatory surge for all cytokines immediately after birth at P0, with a late surge of IL-6 at P56. Serum cytokines were quantified at P0, P7, P14, and P28 using ELISA with electrochemiluminescence according to the manufacturer’s instructions, and plates were read at 620 nm. Cytokine values are represented here in a radar plot, and all cytokines are plotted as percent of maximal value. There were significant increases in all cytokines (IL-1β, IL-10, KC-GRO and IL-6) at P0 in the FEMI group compared to the control group (all p < 0.05). There was also a resurgent increase in IL-6 levels at P56 in the pups with FEMI compared to no FEMI (p < 0.05 by non-parametric Kruskal-Wallis testing), which was the only cytokine that was significantly elevated in the FEMI group compared to control at this late timepoint. Figure adapted with permission from Elgin et al.41. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Supplementary Figure 1: Intestinal injury scoring of H&E stained ileal tissue. Injury scores are determined by a three-point intestinal injury scoring scale (0=normal, 1=mild injury, 2=severe injury) based on degree of villi vacuolization, mucosal ulceration, lamina propria damage, and presence of hemorrhage within villi as previously described43. Figure adapted with permission from Elgin et al.41. Please click here to download this figure.
Supplementary Figure 2: Representative appearance of Alcian Blue/PAS staining of goblet and Paneth cells. Alcian Blue/PAS staining of intestinal tissues allows clear visualization of goblet cells, present in intestinal villi (top panel marked with white arrows, image taken at 20x magnification), and Paneth cells, present in crypts of Lieberkuhn, located below the intestinal villi in the lamina propria (bottom panel marked with yellow arrows, image taken at 60x magnification). Please click here to download this figure.
Chorioamnionitis impacts 2‒4% of term and 25‒30% of preterm deliveries8,9. However, the impact of chorioamnionitis can extend long past birth as it has been shown to have significant effects on the fetus and neonate10,11,12,13,14,15,16. Importantly, chorioamnionitis has been shown to be associated with subsequent development of NEC15,16. While it is still incompletely understood, the pathogenesis of NEC likely involves a combination of intestinal immaturity, dysregulation of the immature immune system, intestinal inflammation, and bacterial translocation, culminating in a final common pathway of intestinal necrosis19. However, a mechanistic link between chorioamnionitis and subsequent development of NEC remains unclear20, and previous animal models of chorioamnionitis have been insufficient to examine this relationship. To address this gap in knowledge, we modified the commonly used LPS-induced murine model of chorioamnionitis and preterm birth34,37,38,39,40 to allow for neonatal birth and survival. In doing so, we have created a model that approximates the inflammatory condition seen in chorioamnionitis42 to study the impact of fetal exposure to maternal inflammation (FEMI) on subsequent intestinal development.
With this protocol, we have demonstrated that this murine model of chorioamnionitis, using LPS-induced FEMI, results in both short and long-term intestinal injury as well as interruption of normal intestinal development, most notably downregulation of both goblet and Paneth cells, both of which provide a first line of innate immunity against intestinal inflammation. The intestinal injury and histologic cellular changes that are seen with this model indicates that it is an effective model to mimic the injury seen in NEC. This is primarily because the downregulation of Paneth cells and goblet cells both have been implicated in the pathogenesis of NEC, and the patterns of histologic injury are similar to what are seen in human cases of NEC41,42,49. Therefore, this LPS-induced FEMI model of chorioamnionitis is an ideal model for investigating the mechanistic link between chorioamnionitis and later intestinal injury, specifically the development of NEC, as well as potential effects of chorioamnionitis on the developing microbiome, which would not be possible with existing models that utilize live bacteria.
In vivo, chorioamnionitis often involves an ascending bacterial infection that often results in preterm rupture of membranes and the clinical phenotype of chorioamnionitis, and animal models of chorioamnionitis exist which more accurately reflect this pathophysiology25,28,30,32. However, because our laboratory studies intestinal development, including the developing microbiome, the presence of live bacteria in a model of chorioamnionitis would confound the microbiome analysis. Therefore, existing models of chorioamnionitis utilizing live bacteria are impractical for investigating the mechanistic link between chorioamnionitis and later development of NEC. In addition, LPS-induced models of chorioamnionitis have already been effective in modeling postnatal white and gray matter brain injury36, demonstrating that this method is an effective way to model morbidities of prematurity that are associated with exposure to chorioamnionitis at the time of birth.
It is also important to note that this model is highly dependent on the dose of LPS used to induce FEMI. The primary critical step in this protocol is induction of FEMI in the pregnant dams with intraperitoneal injection of LPS; therefore, not surprisingly, we have found that the dose of LPS used to induce FEMI is extremely important in the outcomes of these experiments. With initial experiments, a dose of 100 µg/kg of LPS was used, as this LPS dose was not associated with maternal mortality and resulted in approximately 50% neonatal survival as well as significant intestinal injury in offspring41,42.
LPS binds to the Toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4) complex, resulting in aggregation of intracellular signaling proteins, cytokine production, and the initiation of pro-inflammatory signaling50. Toll-like receptors (TLRs) including TLR2, TLR3, TLR4, TLR7, TLR8, and TLR9 are important in the induction of the inflammatory response that is seen with a variety of pathogens and microorganisms such as viruses, bacteria, and fungi51. Interestingly, upregulation of TLR3 has also been shown to correlate with increased histologic intestinal damage and viral shedding in a neonatal murine rotavirus model; furthermore, knockout of TLR3 ameliorated these effects52. Thus, while the model makes use of TLR4 pathways, it is reasonable to assume that stimulation of other TLRs may confer similar findings.
Using this methodology, we have been able to show that LPS injection in pregnant dams causes increases in maternal, placental, and fetal inflammatory markers while sparing the amniotic fluid, as well as inducing direct damage to the placenta42. Interestingly, this methodology showed no alteration of resistance in the uterine arteries. The FEMI model also has a significant impact on the offspring as we have shown that exposed pups have significant intestinal injury42 through an IL-6 dependent pathway41 and can impact important defense mechanisms of the intestine such as goblet cells and Paneth cells41. This injury makes the neonatal offspring increasingly susceptible to subsequent LPS-induced intestinal injury and inflammation41 which may explain why infants exposed to chorioamnionitis have an increased susceptibility to develop NEC.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This work was supported in part through the National Institutes of Health (DK097335 & T32AI007260) and the University of Iowa Stead Family Department of Pediatrics.
10% neutral buffered formalin | Sigma | HT501128 | |
Alcian blue stain | Newcomer supply | 1003A | |
C57Bl6/J mice | Jackson Laboratories | 664 | |
Ethanol | Decon labs | 2701 | |
HCl | Sigma | H1758 | |
Hematoxylin stain | Leica | 381562 | |
LPS | Sigma | L2880 | |
NaHCO3 | Sigma | S6014 | |
Nikon Eclipse Ni-U Microscope | Nikon | 2CE-MQVJ-1 | |
Periodic Acid | ACROS | H5106 | CAS# 10450-59-9 |
RNAlater | Thermofisher | Am7021 | |
Schiff's reagent | Sigma | S5133 | |
Secor Imager 2400 | Meso Scale Discovery (MSD) | ||
V-Plex Assay | Meso Scale Discovery (MSD) | ||
Xylene | Sigma | 534056 |