$$\rightleftharpoonup{xx}$$
$$\longleftharp{xx}$$,
$$\longrightharp{xx}$$,
In this article the procedures for a clip-generated SCC injury in P1 mice are described. The same procedures can also be performed at later stages. Compression injuries were performed successfully at P5, P7, P9 and P12 (Züchner, et al., manuscript in preparation). At all postnatal stages, general anesthesia is obtained with isoflurane vaporized in pure oxygen, but the anesthetic outcome depends greatly on age. In initial attempts at P1-P4, before local anesthesia was introduced into the protocol, it was difficult to obtain a deep and prolonged sedation due to a narrow dose-effect window between insufficient sedation and overdose. In addition, concerns related to a neurotoxic effect of isoflurane in newborn animals have been raised27-30. A combination of isoflurane and the local anesthetic Bupivacaine results in a deeper and more stable anesthesia while permitting an isoflurane dose reduction by a factor of 2-3. Different types of anesthesia have been described for neonatal rodents, including cryoanesthesia31,32, but one potential inconvenience of cryoanesthesia is its neuroprotective effect (reviewed by 33,34), which could complicate the generation of an efficient and reproducible injury. Barbiturate-based anesthesia is considered to have lower efficiency in neonatal mice due to lower levels of serum albumin and body fat than in adults35,36.
Although quite invasive and traumatic, once the procedure is established the mortality rate during surgery is low. However, there are critical steps during the procedure that require particular attention to improve the recovery and survival of the operated mice. One important issue is to select pups that will have the best chance to survive the surgery. When the litter is large the nutritional state of the individual pups varies. In addition to the unavoidable bleeding that occurs during surgery, operated pups spend hours away from the mother, and they often do not drink milk before the next morning. It is thus an advantage to select pups that already have a certain amount of milk in the stomach. This is readily visible through the abdominal skin from P0 to P7.
During the first night the operated pup is at great risk of being cannibalized by the mother. During initial development of this model more than half of the operated mice were missing the following morning, with clear signs of blood in the cage. Necrophagy, cannibalism and infanticide in rodents have been studied for decades37-40. In this study, cannibalism was only witnessed once, but was considered a more likely explanation than necrophagy because the pups that were returned to the cage were typically in such good shape that death by natural causes during the night seemed improbable. This prompted the idea of using a reversible pharmacological agent such as Diazepam to reduce anxiety and aggressiveness in the mother (reviewed by 41). Intraperitoneal injection of Diazepam greatly improved the situation, dropping mortality during the first night from more than 60% to less than 20%.
Reducing litter size by culling and disturbing the litter as little as possible following postoperative return are additional elements that can benefit the operated animals. However, leaving only operated pups with the mother is not beneficial. The best balance of operated/unoperated pups may vary according to the line, but for ICR and SCID-ICR mice leaving 4-5 operated pups (injury or sham) together with 3-4 unoperated pups gave the best results.
In a general sense, the main limitation of this neonatal SCI model is that the neonatal spinal cord differs in many respects from the adult spinal cord, and thus may not provide experimental results that are comparable to those obtained from adult SCI models. Such differences include overall size and volume of the spinal cord, cell number, under-representation of specific cell types such as oligodendrocytes, immature immune responses and immature neuronal circuits. Conclusions drawn from experiments in this model must therefore be considered carefully. On the other hand, the model is relevant for the relatively less investigated scenario of pediatric SCI. Moreover, the apparent weakness with respect to adult SCI models is also a potential strength as it may allow the elucidation of plasticity mechanisms that, though minimally extant in the adult spinal cord, could represent a therapeutic substrate if reinstated. It is conceivable that reinstatement of neonatal or even embryonic conditions could be implemented through the implantation of less developed cells or tissue or by treatment with reagents that engender the adult tissue with earlier developmental characteristics. Using enzymes to eliminate perineuronal nets is an example of the latter approach42,43.
A major issue when establishing an animal model for SCI is to obtain a standardized injury. This is an important aspect that has been addressed in multiple SCI models, e.g., transection, hemisection, impactors, balloon compression, forceps crush, static weight compression, etc. With respect to impacting devices, efforts in this direction have resulted in SCI models in adult rodents where multiple parameters of the impact such as speed, force and duration can be manipulated (reviewed by 44). Another approach, involving less equipment, employs a modification of the Kerr-Lougheed aneurysm clip45,46. These 2 approaches are complementary as the impactor mimics a contusion injury whereas the clip mimics a compression injury with some degree of concurrent ischemia. Because of the substantial size constraints and greater vulnerability of neonatal mice, the higher mortality associated with longer surgeries as well as the costs of developing smaller scale equipment, it was chosen to develop a clip-generated compression rather than an impactor-generated contusion approach. This was accomplished by adapting a commercially available aneurysm mini-clip to accommodate the size of the vertebral column of neonatal mice1. Adding a stopper ensures a standardized compression width, and as long as the tension of the clip compresses to the limit of the stopper, the force of the compression during the static phase at minimal width should vary little. What is not standardized is the velocity of the compression during its dynamic phase, since this will vary as the clip tension changes over its lifetime. As the static phase of the compression lasts much longer than the dynamic phase, and there is little to suggest that the spinal cord tissue exerts much of a counterforce against the mini-clip blades, it is likely that the severity of injury is most dependent on the static phase. This, however, remains to be tested. Injury severity is likely to depend on multiple factors, including the static compression force and duration, the velocity of compression and decompression, the position of the mini-clip, and the number of compressions performed at the same site. Thus, combinatorial variation in these parameters could result in the generation of a spectrum of injury severities from weak to severe. Despite the potential for variability, in our previously published study1 we obtained consistent results at histological, physiological and behavioral levels, so there is little to suggest that acceptable standardization is hard to achieve. We note that in that study we used multiple methods of validation at each level, including behavioral tests such as air-stepping as shown in Figure 5.
In this neonatal SCI model the injury spares a certain proportion of axons and thereby provides a situation favorable for eliciting adaptive plasticity through the re-modeling of spared connections and the formation of new circuits. Moreover, since the neonatal mouse is well suited for investigation by many experimental methods, it is possible to use this model to study functional recovery and adaptive plasticity with an integrative approach, including behavioral tests, retrograde and anterograde axonal tracing, immunohistochemistry, electrophysiology and high-throughput optical recording1. As an example, we took advantage of this integrative approach to demonstrate network re-modeling at the level of specific descending inputs using high-throughput calcium imaging in ex vivo wholemount preparations of the brain stem and injured spinal cord1. This can be pushed further by using neuro-optogenetic and optogenetic pharmacology tools to assess the remodeling of synaptic connections among specific subpopulations of spinal neurons.