$$\rightleftharpoonup{xx}$$
$$\longleftharp{xx}$$,
$$\longrightharp{xx}$$,
Critical steps in the protocol
Our aim is to obtain, characterize and store good quality tissues coming from subjects with detailed history derived from longitudinal observation. In order to reach this goal, it is required to deal with the following key aspects. As described above, the protocol begins with the recruitment of donors, which is the first crucial step. Then, it is necessary that the donors continue the follow-up program and maintain the adhesion to the project over time until the actual donation of the brain. At the time of death, it is necessary for the ABB staff to be promptly notified in order to convene the autopsy team within 24 hours, being important for adequate tissue quality. Fresh cutting of the cerebral hemispheres requires a steady hand and a specific training. To avoid cellular damage caused by slow freezing and obtain good quality slices for the cryostat and Omics, it is important that they are frozen quickly. Considering the speed of penetration of formalin solution (1 mm/hour), to preserve tissue antigenicity the soaking time of the single slice is kept at its minimum.
Troubleshooting of the method
In order to address the critical steps mentioned above we offer the following approach. Donor recruitment and adherence to follow-ups: There are several factors that hinder brain donation including fears of damaging the body’s figure, purity and integrity, or of the possibility of feeling pain after death. Some even worry that the autopsy may be conducted whilst they are still alive70,71. Concerns about disruption of funeral arrangements and financial burden are also present72. Furthermore, a medical personnel’s lack of knowledge about postmortem procedures and the inability to address the concerns of potential donors or their NOK may discourage registration. All these factors may produce a low level of awareness with a low number of enrolled participants and a high possibility of donor loss over time. Indeed, the donor recruitment program should be efficient in spreading awareness, instilling trust and convincing people to register and maintain high rates of follow-up participation. In our experience, this is done through careful selection of potential donors and thorough explanation of the BB’s purposes. We offer educational activities and an empathic approach addressing the fears and needs of both healthy people and those affected with neurodegenerative diseases and their families. We find that potential donors are more likely to give their consent when approached in person. A face-to-face approach creates a relationship based on mutual trust and respect which is fundamental to achieving a high percentage of registration to brain donation and follow-up assessments. A highly trained staff with a strong sense of ethics first approaches the potential donor, discusses the possibility of donating the brain after death, explains the value of human brain tissue to neuroscientific research, and clarifies any doubt regarding postmortem procedures. Favorable word of mouth is equally important. After the brain harvesting, appropriate attention and care is given to recompose the cadaver. It is important to show respect and gratitude to the deceased person by treating the cadaver gently. A few months after, a meeting is scheduled to communicate the results of the neuropathological analysis whenever requested by family members.
The time of death and brain harvesting: When the person accepts, they become a donor and are given an identification card with a number to contact 24 hours/day, 7 days/week (the reception number of ASP Golgi-Redaelli Geriatric Hospital which is connected to us). Moreover, an adhesive tag is given to the relatives to be used in case of hospitalization. The funeral agencies of the area were previously informed to bring the body to the ABB facilities, where the autopsy team is summoned. The autopsy team is composed of a pathologist, a neurologist and/or a neurobiologist, and an anatomical room technician, which are on call from 6 am to 11 pm every day; some trainee students are also frequently present to assist and take pictures.
The precision and consistency of the fresh cutting procedures are ensured by the involvement of the same two operators (a neurologist and a pathologist) who have developed the method and have several years of experience in neuropathology. When freezing the slices, they are put on a prefrozen aluminum tray and covered with an interlocking aluminum plate to keep them well flat. Immediately after, they are put in liquid nitrogen for 3 minutes, before storing them at -80 °C. The slices to be fixed are individually wrapped in gauze, and soaked into a 10% phosphate buffered formalin solution, which is substituted after one day. Subsequently, they are kept in formalin no more than 5 additional days; however, considering that the formalin solution penetrates at 1 mm/day, we would like to shorten furtherly the soaking time.
Limitations of the method
The research method described here only covers a limited geographical area, and the individuals involved in the donation program possess characteristics that do not entirely represent the general population. Although more than acceptable, a postmortem interval up to 24 hours may produce alterations in some protein structures, enzymes and RNA of brain tissue. The determination of AFS and pH may not be entirely adequate for determining tissue quality73 and we are developing other ways of authenticating tissue quality based on RNA integrity.
Concerning the microtome cutting procedure, although very useful for reconstructing anatomical relationships, it should be noted that the use of macrosections is not simple and presents some technical difficulties. Our method is challenging and time-consuming. The costs are quite high and funding is not always easy. The funding comes primarily from public (ASP Golgi-Redaelli Geriatric Hospital) and private resources (Golgi-Cenci Foundation), private donations, non-profit organizations (e.g. “Federazione Alzheimer Italia”) and grants participation.
The significance of the ABB method with respect to existing/alternative methods
At the beginning, our brain donation program targeted individuals participating in the InveCe.Ab longitudinal study. As a consequence, the brains donated are accompanied by detailed clinical, biological and social information collected over the years. The strength of ABB derives precisely from this distinctive origin. Indeed, studying a group of socially and genetically related people who share biological characteristics and environmental exposures enhances statistical analysis. Moreover, the study includes the following benefits: 1) Looking after and providing for the needs of the community (the act of “giving before asking”): people receive a free periodic check-up of which the general practitioner is informed, a telephone number of our secretary is provided for consultations, and severely disabled people are visited at home; 2) Engaging participants, people with public roles and general practitioners in educational activities through the organization of periodic seminars (related to brain healthiness, brain donation and general health), and the planning of thematic courses (e.g. the use of information technology devices for elderly); 3) Meeting people and adopting a face-to-face approach. All these elements constitute the strength of the ABB project. Furthermore, the project improves the clinical abilities of involved medical personnel, as they gain experience in both antemortem assessments and postmortem neuropathological evaluations. In this regard, we would like to mention the very peculiar experience of “The minority aging research study”. This study involved a limited and selected number of African Americans residing in the Chicago area (784 out of 1,357 eligible subjects: response rate of 57%). The participants were visited annually at home and were asked to join the brain donation program. This study is based on an unusual approach with some similarities to ours obtaining high percentages of positive response to the brain donation program (352 donors out of 784 participants were enrolled: 44%), albeit the autopsy rate was not quite satisfactory (53%)74. Just like in “The minority aging research study”, we offer educational activities and an empathic approach, achieving excellent results. In particular, our response rate is 93%, the enrollment percentage is 28.7%, and the autopsy rate at the moment is 67%. These rates show that projects directly engaging people have a more substantial percentage of donations. Other brain donation programs, with less attention into building a relationship with potential donors, generally have a low enrollment percentage, being around 10-15% or less73,75.
There are few previous cohort studies ending with a neuropathological analysis. Moreover, the majority of brain banks and repositories are disease-centered and there is a scarcity of “control” brains from healthy donors compared to the number of “diseased” brains. Only a limited number of BBs are based on population studies involving both diseased and normal subjects in order to study aging trajectories73,74,76,77,78,79,80. Some studies such as “The minority aging research study” in the USA74 and “The Vantaa 85+ study” in Finland76 are similar to ours but they tend to run out with the termination of the cohort. Instead, ABB's donation program is envisioned to continue for a long time in the future, enlisting potential donors and scheduling follow-ups even after the end of the InveCe.Ab longitudinal study. This approach makes our recruitment method similar to that of the "Sun Health Research Institute (SHRI) brain donation program" which is aimed at a retirement community73. The SHRI protocol for brain donation is very efficient with the shortest mean postmortem interval in the world (3.92 hours). Similar to the biggest BBs in the world, the SHRI protocol simply cut the cerebrum, cerebellum and brainstem in the midline (sagittal plane), then one half is dissected fresh and frozen for biochemical studies, while the other is fixed in formalin for the histopathological assessment. However, one of the strengths of the SHRI dissection protocol is the fixation of individual slices instead of the whole hemisphere. Indeed, fixating a hemisphere as a whole is not optimal, because of the different fixation gradients between the surface and the core. Moreover, the cortical proteins may be affected by prolonged exposure to the formalin solution. Thus, the reason why we decided to fix individual slices.
The decision as to which side is fixed or frozen, depends on the singular bank (always the same, randomly assigned or assigned depending on whether the day of dissection is odd or even)31,32,33,34,35. So, biochemical and histopathological analysis are conducted separately on each hemisphere. As many neurological diseases are asymmetrical, our BB offers a unique protocol for slicing fresh specimens: alternate sections from the brainstem and from each hemisphere of cerebellum and cerebrum are retained as fixed or frozen material; a fixed slice on one hemisphere corresponds to a frozen one on the other hemisphere. Our method gives the opportunity to obtain a complete histological characterization of all frozen material and to compare the results from all areas of both sides. As said in the introduction, the method described allows us to obtain as much information as possible from the brain tissue. Furthermore, ABB’s method yields a basic but complete neuropathological characterization, including almost all known brain proteinopathies and vascular pathology. Due to the controversial role of vascular injuries in determining cognitive impairment, we decided to use a double scoring for the vascular burden30,53.
As explained in the protocol, we use a multidisciplinary approach. Although this is a time-consuming and labored method, we believe it provides several advantages for research. For instance, in a previous work, we demonstrated that high tHcy per se, or MTHFR C677T TT associated with the APOE-ε4 allele, may be related to executive dysfunctions rather than memory loss81. Therefore, it may be interesting to evaluate subjects with this particular genetic profile at a neuropathological level. This is an example of how such in-depth follow-up is useful in creating new research hypotheses verifiable through investigation of biological material collected in our bank. Another demonstration of the advantage of our approach is the inclusion of QEEG among the assessments we routinely perform, for its originality and the relative ease of use. Indeed, EEG detects the synaptic activity of the cerebral cortex by recording the electrical potentials of dendrites belonging to cortical pyramidal neurons82. QEEG can be considered a biomarker for estimation of cortical synaptic activity which is related to cognition83. Particularly, a decrease in alpha rhythms in the posterior part of the brain with a general increase of lower frequencies (theta and delta rhythms) has been related to cortical connection breakdown. It should be considered that most of the diagnostic correlation studies have been based on a clinical diagnosis that is only a probable and not a definite diagnosis84,85,86,87. Only very few targeted studies have compared QEEG data with the neuropathological picture to investigate the correlation between QEEG and LTS variants88,89, and the distinction between FTLD and AD83. By ending our study with a definition of the neuropathological diagnosis, it is then possible to correctly interpret the observations made on the cerebral electrical activity. Moreover, performing serial QEEG in each subject we can track intra-individual EEG waves trajectory and their correlations with the neuropathological picture. Following individual modifications of cortical electrical activity over time can lead to a better understanding of its meaning as a biomarker for incipient dementia.
Future applications and direction of the method
Implementing the tissue distribution is one of our main prospective goals. In order to do this, we just established a scientific commission including the director of the GC Foundation (geriatrician), an academic of Neurology from the University of Pavia, a neurologist and a pathologist both from the GC Foundation & the Geriatric Hospital ASP Golgi-Redaelli. When distributing brain tissue, histological slides, and other biological samples, it is important to remember that donors agreed to the donation for the sake of research. The distribution of material should therefore take place prudently, just as described in the BNE Code of Conduct40. Any party submitting a request for material should indicate the type and quantity of the sample needed, provide a description of the research project and how the samples will be used, and whenever possible, supply evidence of previous publications (for the transfer agreement, see Figure 9). The brain bank does not work for financial gain. So, the fees paid by researchers should only cover the expenses of the tissue procurement, processing, storage and distribution.
Plans to start analyzing cases with exome sequencing and Omics techniques, such as proteomics and transcriptomics, are in motion. Our alternate sampling methodology will allow omics studies to be performed on histologically well-defined tissues from both hemispheres. Through this approach, it will be possible to compare the pattern of gene activation in different brain areas of the same hemisphere and in the corresponding areas of the other hemisphere, and be able to correlate gene activation with histopathology. In this field, deep learning applications would be of great interest including computerized analysis of histological slides and cutting-edge correlation of clinical, histological and omics data. Other correlations between many different variables can be identified as well as other possible technological applications. The availability of frozen material from both hemispheres will allow an accurate topography of gene activation and protein distribution. This will be of particular interest even in healthy subjects, considering that both brain functions and some diseases are asymmetrical.
Moreover, we can obtain cell cultures from well-characterized brain donors. Indeed, cell cultures from the leptomeninges of harvested brains supply living cells that can be used for further investigation of disease or aging mechanisms, by means of the induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) technology which involves reprogramming leptomeningeal fibroblasts and differentiating them into neural cells in advanced models90.
As brains age, different profiles of change can occur at the molecular, cellular and tissue level. Every brain is unique. Each has its own way of responding to internal and external stressors; some resists while others succumb and display distinct pathologies. Discrepancies between the clinical presentation and the neuropathological picture often exist because the topography of the lesions, rather than their molecular nature, determines the clinical presentation. The correct and definite diagnosis could only be achieved by combining the clinical syndrome with the neuropathological findings which often add important etiological clues necessary to unravel the pathogenesis of the diseases. In Europe, there is an effort to create a standard approach to neuropathological diagnosis. Our diagnostic protocol almost completely follows the recently published guidelines on neuropathological diagnosis for brain banking91. This will allow us to collect and share well-documented brain tissue, with the prospective goal of establishing the first Italian Brain Bank. Indeed, in Italy there are brain repositories but not brain banks based on cohort studies. Our aim is to develop a method for brain tissue harvesting that can be implemented broadly across Italy, to establish a network that uses a common protocol and shares comparable material. In order to do so, the involvement of other research centers and the creation of a specific website are among the main objectives for the future.
Innovative technologies are constantly being used for the analysis of the molecular nature of neurodegenerative diseases and for biomarker identification. In this context, there will be an increasing need for brains accompanied by information about cognitive and aging trajectories obtained through longitudinal studies, emphasizing the importance of a neuropathologically verified epidemiological approach92.