What is a confederate in psychology research?

A confederate is a research actor who secretly participates in an experiment alongside actual subjects. Confederates follow the researcher's directions to create controlled social settings while participants believe they are interacting with genuine participants. This allows researchers to reliably capture naive reactions and study complex social behaviors that would be difficult to observe naturally.

How does perceived social status affect mimicry behavior?

In the confederate experiment, participants who believed the confederate held higher power as a residence hall assistant mimicked significantly more behaviors than those who thought the confederate was an equal-status student. This demonstrates that perceived social power influences whether people unconsciously imitate others' actions, revealing a key mechanism in social influence and status-based behavior.

What is the two-group design used in this confederate study?

The two-group design divides participants into two conditions: one group believes the confederate has higher power, while the other believes the confederate has equal power. Researchers then measure the dependent variable—the number of behaviors mimicked—across both groups to test whether perceived status influences mimicry. This design isolates the effect of the independent variable on participant behavior.

What specific behaviors does the confederate perform in the mimicry experiment?

The confederate performs seven key behaviors in sequence while solving math problems: playing with hair, putting a pen in their mouth, tapping fingers on the desk, touching their face, wrinkling their nose, whistling, and leaning back in the chair. Researchers tally how many of these behaviors participants unconsciously imitate while scoring the confederate's math performance.

Why is deception necessary in confederate experiments?

Deception is necessary because if participants knew a confederate was acting, they would not display natural, unconscious behaviors. Participants must genuinely believe they are observing another real participant to produce authentic mimicry responses. After the experiment concludes, researchers debrief participants and explain why the deception was essential for capturing genuine social behavior.

How do confederates help researchers study memory and social influence?

Confederates enable researchers to introduce controlled social elements into experiments. In memory studies, confederates provide misinformation to test whether social influence affects recall accuracy. In attraction studies, confederates interact with babies to measure whether witnessing nurturing behavior influences how women perceive attractiveness. This approach reveals how social context shapes cognition and perception.

What materials and setup are required to conduct a confederate mimicry experiment?

The experiment requires informed consent forms, pens, GRE-level math problem sheets, a one-way mirror for observation, and a behavior tally chart. The one-way mirror allows researchers to observe participants secretly while participants believe they are watching another person solve problems. This setup ensures participants remain unaware they are being observed, preserving the authenticity of their mimicry responses.

Experimentation using a Confederate

0 views06:12 min

1. Define key variables.

Create an operational definition (i.e., a clear description of exactly what a researcher means by a concept) of power.
1. For the purposes of this experiment, power is measured by relative authority on the college campus, e.g., a residence hall assistant has more power than a student that does not hold this position.
Create an operational definition (i.e., a clear description of exactly what a researcher means by a concept) of imitation.
1. For purposes of this experiment, imitation is defined as the participant’s non-conscious mimicking of the confederate by making similar movements with their feet and hands.

2. Conduct the study.

Meet the student/participant at the lab.
Provide participant with informed consent, a brief description of the research, a sense of the procedure, an indication of potential risks/benefits, the right of withdrawal at any time, and a manner to get help if they experience discomfort.
Have the participant sit at a desk on the window side of a one-way mirror.
Tell the participant that you would like them to remember the behaviors of another participant (a confederate in actuality) who will sit on the mirror side of the one-way mirror while they work on GRE Math problems (Figure 1).¹

Figure 1: An example of the GRE math problems given to the confederate.
Train the confederate.
1. Confederates, also known as stooges, are part of the experiment and act exactly as the researcher instructs. Participants are led to believe that a confederate is a participant.
2. Train the confederate to engage in 7 key behaviors: playing with their hair, putting a pen in their mouth, tapping their fingers, touching their face, wrinkling their nose, making whistling sounds, and leaning back in their chair.
3. For consistency, the confederate should match each behavior to a specific question on the GRE math problems. For example, when the confederate works on problem 1, they should play with hair, when they work on question 2, they should put a pen in their mouth, for question 3, they should tap their fingers, etc. This will ensure that all behaviors occur at the same relative time for all participants.
Lead the confederate to their chair in front of the mirror-side of the one-way mirror.
Treat the confederate like a participant, giving them informed consent (as described in 2.2 above), and then explain that the participant will complete the sheet of GRE math problems.
1. On the window side of the one-way mirror, the participant has clear sight and sound of this interaction between the researcher and the confederate.
Return to the participant with a pen and a copy of the GRE problems. Instruct the participant to mark ones they think the confederate got correct with a star, and those they think the confederate got incorrect with an X.
1. In one condition, tell the participant that the confederate is a head residence hall assistant on campus.
2. In the other condition tell the participant that the confederate is another participant “just like you.”
Sit off to the side of the participant and record the participant’s behaviors on a chart (Figure 2).

Figure 2: Chart used by experimenter to record participant’s behavior.

3. Debrief the participant.

Tell the participant the nature of the study.
1. “Thank you for participating. In this study I was trying to determine if a fellow participant’s perceived power or authority would increase the chances that a participant like you would mimic their behavior. There were two groups in the study, one group was told the person they were observing is a residence hall assistant, while the other group was told they were just another participant. We hypothesized that those who observed the resident hall assistant would be more likely to mimic their behavior because they are an authority figure.”
Explain explicitly why deception was necessary for the experiment.
1. “We want to tell you about the deception we used in this study. We used deception by telling you the person you observed was another participant, but in reality they were a part of the study and served as a confederate. We did this to make the experiment feel real and to ensure that person being observed acting similarly for each participant in the study. If participants were to know the true reasoning and hypothesis behind the study, they may perform in an unnatural way by trying to live up to the experimenter’s perceived expectations. To eliminate this problem, it was necessary for us to use the confederate. Because of the nature of the deception, it is quite natural for participants to not realize that they were being deceived.”