Cite this ArticleCopy Citation | Download Citations | Reprints and Permissions
Lenell, C., Shembel, A. C., Johnson, A. M. Preparation of the Rat Vocal Fold for Neuromuscular Analyses. J. Vis. Exp. (159), e61327, doi:10.3791/61327 (2020).
The purpose of this tutorial is to describe the preparation of the rat vocal fold for histochemical neuromuscular study. This protocol outlines procedures for rat laryngeal dissection, flash-freezing, and cryosectioning of the vocal folds. This study describes how to cryosection vocal folds in both longitudinal and cross-sectional planes. A novelty of this protocol is the laryngeal tracking during cryosectioning that ensures accurate identification of the intrinsic laryngeal muscles and reduces the chance of tissue loss. Figures demonstrate the progressive cryosectioning in both planes. Twenty-nine rat hemi-larynges were cryosectioned and tracked from the emergence of the thyroid cartilage to the appearance of the first section that included the full vocal fold. The full vocal fold was visualized for all animals in both planes. There was high variability in the distance from the appearance of the thyroid cartilage to the appearance of the full vocal fold in both planes. Weight was not correlated to depth of laryngeal landmarks, suggesting individual variability and other factors related to tissue preparation may be responsible for the high variability in the appearance of landmarks during sectioning. This study details a methodology and presents morphological data for preparing the rat vocal fold for histochemical neuromuscular investigation. Due to high individual variability, laryngeal landmarks should be closely tracked during cryosectioning to prevent oversectioning tissue and tissue loss. The use of a consistent methodology, including adequate tissue preparation and awareness of landmarks within the rat larynx, will assist with consistent results across studies and aid new researchers interested in using the rat vocal fold as a model to investigate laryngeal neuromuscular mechanisms.
The rat larynx is a well-established model to investigate structural and functional neuromuscular laryngeal adaptations to development, aging, disease, and pharmacological agents1,2,3,4,5. Consistency of histological methods is critical to this line of work, as there are multiple intricacies involved in muscle preparation and analysis as well as challenges associated with laryngeal size, shape, and topography of the muscles encapsulated within the laryngeal cartilages1,6,7,8,9,10,11. Due to the small size of the rat intrinsic laryngeal muscles, systematic embedding, freezing, and cryosectioning are critical to achieve consistent and accurate results. For example, when sectioning the rat vocal fold in the coronal plane, the neuromuscular junctions (NMJs) of four of the intrinsic laryngeal muscles are located within less than 1.8 mm of tissue depth11. Therefore, precise monitoring of laryngeal muscle anatomy during cryosectioning is imperative to accurately identify the section(s) of interest and prevent oversectioning of tissue. Oversectioning of the target muscle can result in inaccurate identification of number and topography of NMJs11 or can result in overall reductions in sample size if the target muscle is discarded due to landmark orientation confusion12. As novel models for the study of laryngeal muscle and their respective adaptations are developed, standard operating procedures are essential to ensure results are precise, reliable, and reproducible across studies.
The objective of this article is to detail preparation of the rat vocal fold for optimal longitudinal and cross-sectional analysis. Detailed methods used regularly in our laboratory are described to identify target muscle landmarks during cryosectioning. Although similar methods are used in several laboratories, greater detail is provided here than in the literature to ensure reliable and accurate replication when implemented by novice investigators. The goal of this tutorial is to provide a standard methodology for immunohistochemical (IHC) evaluation of the rat vocal fold to improve consistency across laboratories and investigations.
This study was performed in compliance with the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee of New York University School of Medicine.
1. Dissect rat larynx
- Euthanize rat according to the institutionally approved protocol. Shave the ventral neck from the mandible to manubrium and swab with alcohol to prevent fur contamination in the tissue specimens.
- Under a dissecting scope with 10x magnification excise the entire larynx by creating a midline neck incision with a scalpel until the trachea is exposed.
- Separate the ventral extrinsic laryngeal muscles at the midline to expose the larynx using forceps and dissecting scissors or a scalpel.
- Sever the trachea caudal to the third tracheal ring and make an incision rostral to the hyoid bone to excise the whole larynx using dissecting scissors.
- Remove the extrinsic laryngeal tissues (esophagus, thyroid gland, and extrinsic laryngeal muscles) from the larynx using microdissection tools (tweezers, pins, and microscissors) under magnification.
- With microscissors, bisect the larynx dorsally between the arytenoids using the midline between the posterior cricoarytenoid muscles as a landmark. Pin lateral walls of the larynx to expose the vocal folds and then bisect ventrally through the midline of the thyroid cartilage between the anterior commissure of the vocal folds with microscissors (Figure 1).
NOTE: This step can be optional; it can be skipped to keep the larynx whole. Bisection of larynges allow multiple immunostaining techniques by separately using the right and left sides of the same larynx.
- Rinse each hemi-larynx in phosphate buffered solution (PBS) for ~10 s and delicately dry with a task wiper to reduce ice crystal formation during freezing.
2. Fix and/or flash-freeze laryngeal tissue
NOTE: Fixation may not be ideal for all immunostaining protocols. Often laryngeal tissues are flash-frozen fresh immediately following dissection. Skip step 2.1 to flash-freeze laryngeal tissue without fixation.
- To fix hemi-larynges place tissues in centrifuge tube filled with 4% formaldehyde in PBS for 1 h at room temperature on an orbital shaker at 70 rpm. Transfer tissues to a clean centrifuge tube and rinse 3x for 20 min in PBS. Then transfer to a clean centrifuge tube and submerge in a 20% sucrose/5% glycerol solution (~18 h or until tissue sinks) at 4 °C.
CAUTION: Formaldehyde is hazardous and should be used in a fume hood along with appropriate personal protective equipment.
- Place all hemi-larynges in a uniform position into a cryo-mold filled with optimal cutting temperature (OCT) compound. For a hemilarynx, place the tissue with the medial surface of the vocal fold facing the bottom of the cryomold and the longitudinal aspect of the vocal fold parallel to the lower edge of the cryomold opening. For whole larynges, place the tissue with the posterior cricoarytenoids facing the bottom of the cryomold and the longitudinal aspect of the vocal fold parallel to the lower edge of the cryomold opening.
NOTE: Consistent laryngeal orientation within OCT compound is critical for cryosectioning of the rat vocal fold. Once the hemilarynx is embedded and frozen, it must be thawed to change its orientation, thereby introducing risks of tissue damage from multiple thaw-freeze cycles.
- Flash-freeze tissues using isopentane (2-methylbutane) chilled in a steel beaker surrounded by liquid nitrogen.
NOTE: The isopentane reaches optimal temperature for tissue freezing when white precipitates start to form on the sides and bottom of the beaker13. Isopentane is used because it has a higher thermal conductivity than liquid nitrogen, which helps prevent cracking of the tissue block during rapid freezing. For a more detailed description of freezing tissue in OTC refer to Kumar et al.13.
- Wrap each mold in prelabeled foil and place in an individual freezer bag to prevent dehydration and immediately store on dry ice until transferred for storage in a -80 °C freezer.
3. Cryosection hemilarynx in cross-sectional plane
- Set chamber temperature in the cryostat to -20 °C, which is in the middle of the temperature range (15−25 °C) recommended for muscle tissue sectioning by the manufacturer’s manual.
- Set cryostat section thickness to 10 µm thick sections.
NOTE: For muscle fiber cross-sectional analysis, 10 µm thick sections are optimal to allow for complete staining and robust imaging intensity of the labeled muscle fibers for fiber typing analysis14,15,16. Some protocols may require different section thickness depending on neuromuscular targets.
- Transfer tissues to the cryostat chamber, add a uniform layer of OCT compound on the cryostat specimen disk (chuck), and place the embedded tissue block on top of the OCT compound on the specimen disk. To obtain cross-sections of the vocal fold for thyroarytenoid (TA) muscle fiber analysis, affix the specimen to the chuck so that the ventral thyroid cartilage faces the cryostat blade and the arytenoid cartilage faces the specimen disk.
NOTE: It is critical to note that these landmarks are not visible at this stage, due to the OCT compound becoming white and opaque when frozen. This lack of visibility is why it is critical to note the orientation of the hemilarynx during the flash freezing stage.
- Trim OCT compound by advancing the specimen head by 100 µm until the ventral portion of the thyroid cartilage appears.
- Then trim and track 30 µm sections from the onset of the thyroid cartilage until the lamina propria, medial TA muscles, and lateral TA muscle are exposed.
NOTE: Laryngeal landmarks should be tracked and noted from the onset of the thyroid cartilage every 100 µm to ensure the angle of sectioning is not oblique. Figure 2 represents the two sets of laryngeal landmarks in the cross-sectional plane at 10x magnification.
- Once the target TA muscle is reached, collect sections on positively charged slides at 10 µm.
- Store sections in PBS at 4 °C to retain moisture until they are ready to be stained.
NOTE: Fixed tissue can be stored in PBS up to one week depending on IHC target whereas unfixed tissue should be immediately processed.
4. Cryosection hemilarynx in longitudinal plane
- With the cryostat chamber again set to -20 °C, change the section thickness to 30 µm.
NOTE: For NMJ analysis, a tissue thickness between 30−60 µm can be used to capture several complete NMJs within the laryngeal muscles without fragmentation of either the nerve terminal or motor endplate11,12,17.
- To obtain longitudinal vocal fold sections for NMJ analysis of the TA muscle, affix the specimens to the chuck so that the epiglottis is oriented towards the cryostat blade and the tracheal lumen faces down towards the specimen disk.
- Trim the OCT compound by advancing the specimen head by 100 µm until the thyroid cartilage appears.
- Trim and track sections of 30 µm from the onset of the thyroid until the lamina propria and medial and lateral divisions of the TA muscle are exposed.
NOTE: Five sets of laryngeal landmarks in the longitudinal plane are recommended to track tissue depth progression towards the target TA muscle. Figure 3 represents the laryngeal landmarks in the longitudinal plane at 10x magnification.
- Once the target TA muscle is reached, collect sections on positively charged slides at 30 µm.
- Store sections in PBS at 4 °C to retain moisture until they are ready to be stained.
The representative results were part of an ongoing investigation of the effects of vocal exercise on the laryngeal neuromuscular system. Twenty-nine male Fischer 344/brown Norway rats (12 9-month-old, 17 24-month-old) were weighed and euthanized with CO2 inhalation followed by a bilateral thoracotomy.
The procedures followed the outlined protocol to label NMJs and fiber size of the lateral and medial TA muscles. The distance between laryngeal landmarks was tracked in both longitudinal and cross-sectional planes using laryngeal muscles and surrounding cartilages to determine progression during cryosectioning (Table 1). Tracking commenced at the first appearance of the thyroid cartilage in both directional planes. Figure 2 illustrates the appearance of laryngeal landmarks during cross-sectional cryosectioning in temporal order with the thyroid (Figure 2a,b) appearing prior to the medial TA muscle and to the lamina propria (Figure 2c,d). Figure 3 illustrates the appearance of laryngeal landmarks during longitudinal cryosectioning in temporal order with the alar muscle (Figure 3a,b) appearing prior to the medial TA muscle (Figure 3c,d) and to the lamina propria (Figure 3e,f).
In both directional planes, distances among landmarks greatly varied for individual animals.
Weight and laryngeal landmark appearances had weak to moderate correlations for young rats and weak correlations for aged rats (Table 2 and Table 3). Distances among landmarks within each plane were moderately to strongly correlated for both age groups, but weakly correlated between the two dissection planes. Therefore, variability in landmark appearance could not be accounted for by weight or individual variations in laryngeal size.
Figure 1: A rat larynx dorsally bisected between the arytenoid cartilages (ArC).
The right side of the hemi-larynx is annotated with landmarks in the longitudinal plane (LZ1-LZ5) corresponding to the five longitudinal landmarks in Table 1. The left side of the hemi-larynx is annotated with landmarks in the cross-sectional plane (CZ1 and CZ2) that correspond to the beginning of the lateral TA muscle and full cross-section of the vocal fold respectively. VF = vocal fold, CrC = cricoid cartilage, AlC = alar cartilage, and T1 = first tracheal ring. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 2: Two cross-sections imaged at 10x magnification in brightfield (right) and in the fluorescent 488 channel (left) following immunostaining for laminin to outline muscle fibers.
The sections (from top to bottom) show the progression during cryosectioning in temporal order with the thyroid (a,b) appearing prior to the medial TA muscle and to the lamina propria of the vocal fold (c,d). ThC = thyroid cartilage, LTA = lateral thyroarytenoid, and MTA = medial thyroarytenoid. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
Figure 3: Three longitudinal sections imaged at 10x magnification in brightfield (right) and in the fluorescent 488 channel (left) following immunostaining for neuromuscular junctions.
The sections (from top to bottom) show the progression during cryosectioning in temporal order with the alar muscle (a,b) appearing prior to the medial TA muscle (c,d) and to the lamina propria (e,f) of the vocal fold. AlC = alar cartilage, ThC = thyroid cartilage, ArC = arytenoid cartilage, LTA = lateral thyroarytenoid, MTA = medial thyroarytenoid, and SCA = superior cricoarytenoid. Please click here to view a larger version of this figure.
|Longitudinal landmarks||Mean (standard deviation) in μm||Range in μm|
|1. All three major cartilages (thyroid, alar, arytenoid) appeared with emergence of muscle fibers||1,591 (665)||350–2,800|
|2. Superior cricoarytenoid (SCA), alar cricoarytenoid (ACA), and lateral thyroarytenoid (LTA) muscles appeared||2,344 (591)||91–3,500|
|3. ACA and LTA muscles extended completely without fragmentation||2,631 (532)||1505–3,640|
|4. Arytenoid cartilage enlarged, ACA disappeared, medial thyroarytenoid (MTA) muscle emerged||2,948 (606)||1765–4,305|
|5. Target full vocal fold section: LTA and MTA muscles extended completely without fragmentation and lamina propria emerged||3,131 (542)||2205–4410|
|1. LTA muscle appeared||303 (138)||110–690|
|2. MTA muscle appeared and was ~50% of the LTA size with clear lamina propria and epithelium noted.||482 (167)||210–850|
Table 1: Distances in µm from the first appearance of the thyroid cartilage to each laryngeal landmark during cryosectioning (n = 29).
Table 2: Results of Pearson correlation between weight and the depth of laryngeal landmarks in the cross-sectional (CSA) and longitudinal planes for young male rats. LTA = lateral thyroarytenoid, MTA = medial thyroarytenoid, SCA = superior cricoarytenoid, and LP = lamina propria.
Table 3: Results of Pearson correlation between weight and the depth of laryngeal landmarks in the cross-sectional (CSA) and longitudinal planes for old male rats. LTA = lateral thyroarytenoid, MTA = medial thyroarytenoid, SCA = superior cricoarytenoid, and LP = lamina propria.
Preparing rat vocal folds for neuromuscular analysis can present with various challenges. Not only are laryngeal muscles small and surrounded by cartilage, thereby making it difficult to directly extract target muscle, high variability was also found between animals in the depth of laryngeal anatomical landmarks. For muscle the cross-section plane protocol, complete vocal fold sections appeared between 21−85 sections (10 µm per section) after the initial appearance of the ventral thyroid cartilage, which is quite a bit fewer than the 63−126 sections (35 µm per section) in the longitudinal plane for NMJ analysis protocols (Table 1).
Variability was noted in distances between laryngeal landmarks despite the uniform embedding, orienting, and sectioning of tissues for each type of protocol. Furthermore, differences in body weight did not account for variability in the wide ranges of tissue depth from one set of laryngeal landmarks to the next. This variability in distance between laryngeal landmarks may be due to individual differences in laryngeal anatomy across animals, small differences in orientation of larynges in the cryomold within the OCT compound at the time of dissection, or how the specimens were placed on the specimen disk within the cryostat when sectioning (i.e., the amount of OCT compound placed on the specimen disk prior to mounting or slight differences in angle of placement).
With an understanding that these slight differences in specimen preparation can lead to substantial variability in depth of laryngeal tissue landmarks, it is critical that novice investigators have a reference map from which to work. Outlined study protocols defining methods to identify the muscle(s) of interest and prevent protocol pitfalls—such as the ones outlined in this document—can improve reproducibility and prevent unwanted tissue loss.
Although this study focused on the TA muscle, this methodology is applicable for other intrinsic laryngeal muscles as well. For example, sectioning in the longitudinal vocal fold plane yields longitudinal muscle fiber sections of the alar, lateral TA, medial TA, lateral cricoarytenoid, and superior cricoarytenoid muscles, and cross-sections of the posterior cricoarytenoid muscles. Sectioning in the cross-sectional vocal fold plane yields cross-sections of the alar, lateral TA, medial TA, lateral cricoarytenoid, superior cricoarytenoid, and cricothyroid muscles, as well as longitudinal sections of the posterior cricoarytenoid muscles. Additionally, although this study did not include female rats, differences between male and female rats in laryngeal landmark appearance are not expected because sexual dimorphism within the rat larynx is muscle specific and not related to laryngeal framework anatomy16,18.
The variability in distance between laryngeal landmarks can make cryosectioning the rat vocal fold difficult for novice investigators. This study demonstrated that despite consistency in how the rat larynges were frozen, embedded, and cryosectioned, the distance between laryngeal landmarks varied greatly; animal weight did not account for this variability. This study provides detailed procedures with associated images on how to appropriately prepare laryngeal muscle tissue and identify laryngeal landmarks for neuromuscular histological investigation of the rat vocal fold.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
This research was supported by grants F31DC017053-01A1 (Lenell, PI) and K23DC014517 (Johnson, PI) from the National Institute on Deafness and other Communication Disorders of the National Institutes of Health.
|2-Methylbutane Certified||Fisher Chemical||35514|
|Cryo Tongs SS||Thermo Scientific||11679123|
|Cryostat blades||C.L. Sturkey D554X50||22-210-045|
|Disposable Base Molds 15mm x 15mm||Thermo Scientific||41-741|
|Dissection kit||Thermo Scientific||9996969|
|DPBS - Dulbecco's Phosphate-Buffered Saline||Gibco||14190136|
|Frozen Section Medium||Fisher Healthcare||23-730-571|
|Immunostain Moisture Chamber||Ted Pella Inc||NC9425474|
|Non-Woven Sponges, 4 Ply||Quick Medical||9023|
|Paraformaldehyde, 16% w/v aq. soln., methanol free||Alfa Aesar||50-00-0|
|Premium Microcentrifuge Tubes||Fisherbrand||5408129|
|Specimen Storage Bags||Fisherbrand||19240093|
|Stainless Steel Graduated Measure 32 oz/100 mL||Polar Ware||114231B|
|Superfrost Plus Microscope Slides||Fisherbrand||12-550-15|
|Task wiper||Kimberly-Clark Professional™ 34155||06666A|
|Vannas Pattern Scissors||Assi||ASSI.SAS15RV|
|NOTE: For all supplies, these are examples of equipment to purchase. The exact model is not necessary to complete our methods.|
- Connor, N. P., Suzuki, T., Lee, K., Sewall, G. K., Heisey, D. M. Neuromuscular junction changes in aged rat thyroarytenoid muscle. Annals of Otology, Rhinology and Laryngology. 111, (7), Pt 1 579-586 (2002).
- Suzuki, T., et al. Age-Related Alterations in Myosin Heavy Chaing Isoforms in Rat Intrinsic Laryngeal Muscles. Annals of Otology, Rhinology and Laryngology. 111, (11), 962 (2002).
- Johnson, A. M., Grant, L. M., Schallert, T., Ciucci, M. R. Changes in Rat 50-kHz Ultrasonic Vocalizations During Dopamine Denervation and Aging: Relevance to Neurodegeneration. Current Neuropharmacology. 13, (2), 211-219 (2015).
- Wright, J. M., Gourdon, J. C., Clarke, P. B. Identification of multiple call categories within the rich repertoire of adult rat 50-kHz ultrasonic vocalizations: effects of amphetamine and social context. Psychopharmacology. 211, (1), 1-13 (2010).
- Bowers, J. M., Perez-Pouchoulen, M., Edwards, N. S., McCarthy, M. M. Foxp2 mediates sex differences in ultrasonic vocalization by rat pups and directs order of maternal retrieval. Journal of Neuroscience. 33, (8), 3276-3283 (2013).
- Basken, J. N., Connor, N. P., Ciucci, M. R. Effect of aging on ultrasonic vocalizations and laryngeal sensorimotor neurons in rats. Experimental Brain Research. 219, (3), 351-361 (2012).
- Ciucci, M. R., et al. Reduction of dopamine synaptic activity: degradation of 50-kHz ultrasonic vocalization in rats. Behavioral Neuroscience. 123, (2), 328-336 (2009).
- Ciucci, M. R., Vinney, L., Wahoske, E. J., Connor, N. P. A translational approach to vocalization deficits and neural recovery after behavioral treatment in Parkinson disease. Journal of Communication Disorders. 43, (4), 319-326 (2010).
- Nagai, H., Ota, F., Konopacki, R., Connor, N. P. Discoordination of laryngeal and respiratory movements in aged rats. American Journal of Otolaryngology. 26, (6), 377-382 (2005).
- Ma, S. T., Maier, E. Y., Ahrens, A. M., Schallert, T., Duvauchelle, C. L. Repeated intravenous cocaine experience: development and escalation of pre-drug anticipatory 50-kHz ultrasonic vocalizations in rats. Behavioural Brain Research. 212, (1), 109-114 (2010).
- Inagi, K., Schultz, E., Ford, C. N. An anatomic study of the rat larynx: establishing the rat model for neuromuscular function. Otolaryngology and Head and Neck Surgery. 118, (1), 74-81 (1998).
- Lenell, C., Newkirk, B., Johnson, A. M. Laryngeal Neuromuscular Response to Short- and Long-Term Vocalization Training in Young Male Rats. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research. 62, (2), 247-256 (2019).
- Kumar, A., Accorsi, A., Rhee, Y., Girgenrath, M. Do's and don'ts in the preparation of muscle cryosections for histological analysis. Journal of Visualized Experiments. (99), e52793 (2015).
- McMullen, C. A., Andrade, F. H. Functional and morphological evidence of age-related denervation in rat laryngeal muscles. Journals of Gerontology. Series A: Biological Sciences and Medical Sciences. 64, (4), 435-442 (2009).
- McMullen, C. A., et al. Chronic stimulation-induced changes in the rodent thyroarytenoid muscle. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research. 54, (3), 845-853 (2011).
- Lenell, C., Johnson, A. M. Sexual dimorphism in laryngeal muscle fibers and ultrasonic vocalizations in the adult rat. Laryngoscope. 127, (8), 270-276 (2017).
- Johnson, A. M., Ciucci, M. R., Connor, N. P. Vocal training mitigates age-related changes within the vocal mechanism in old rats. Journals of Gerontology. Series A: Biological Sciences and Medical Sciences. 68, (12), 1458-1468 (2013).
- Feng, X., Zhang, T., Ralston, E., Ludlow, C. L. Differences in neuromuscular junctions of laryngeal and limb muscles in rats. Laryngoscope. 122, (5), 1093-1098 (2012).