Cancer is a complex disease that is influenced by the tissue surrounding the tumor as well as local pro- and anti-inflammatory mediators. Therefore, orthotropic injection models, rather than subcutaneous models may be useful to study cancer progression in a manner that better mimics human pathology.
Breast cancer growth can be studied in mice using a plethora of models. Genetic manipulation of breast cancer cells may provide insights into the functions of proteins involved in oncogenic progression or help to discover new tumor suppressors. In addition, injecting cancer cells into mice with different genotypes might provide a better understanding of the importance of the stromal compartment. Many models may be useful to investigate certain aspects of disease progression but do not recapitulate the entire cancerous process. In contrast, breast cancer cells engraftment to the mammary fat pad of mice better recapitulates the location of the disease and presence of the proper stromal compartment and therefore better mimics human cancerous disease. In this article, we describe how to implant breast cancer cells into mice orthotopically and explain how to collect tissues to analyse the tumor milieu and metastasis to distant organs. Using this model, many aspects (growth, angiogenesis, and metastasis) of cancer can be investigated simply by providing a proper environment for tumor cells to grow.
Cancer is a very complex disease that has been subject to studies for over centuries. Breast cancer is the most common cancer type; it occurs predominantly in females but may sporadically also occur in males27. The disease is mainly caused by the loss of control mechanism governing cell division which in turn leads to an infinite growth of cells in the body. These malfunctions can be caused by several mechanisms: first, healthy cells need growth signals from the surrounding cells in order to proliferate whereas cancer cells make their own growth factors and increase the expression of growth factor receptors thus obtaining a higher proliferative rate1; second, cancer cells are less susceptible to anti-proliferative signals8; third, to balance the cell number in the body cell death is also required; however, cancer cells escape from programmed cell death, termed apoptosis14; fourth, cells adhere to extracellular matrices in order to survive but tumor cells can grow without the need of attachment and show resistance to anoikis19; fifth, activation of telomerase circumvents the telomere shortening and prevents the replicative senescence21; last but not least, skipping of DNA quality control following mitosis results in altered genetic content15,16. In order to identify oncogenes or tumor suppressors that play a role in this deregulated proliferation, tumor growth experiments in mice are crucial.
Primary tumor growth is generally not the main reason of death. Migration of cancer cells from the primary site to a secondary site, termed metastasis, is the leading cause of death in most cancer patients22. Metastasis entails tumor cell invasion, intravasation, travelling through the circulation, avoiding immune attack, extravasation and growth at the secondary site. Epithelial to mesenchymal transition (EMT) is a key process in metastasis and involves a switch in gene expression profiles yielding cells with higher motility and invasiveness, which are pre-requisites for the metastasizing cell12. As the cancerous process is the resultant of a combination of various actions, including reciprocal interactions between cancer cells, stromal cells and pro- and anti-inflammatory cells, an in vitro approach to cancer often does not provide full insight into the cancerous process. Similarly, anticancer treatments impacting the tumor vasculature can often not be studied in vitro, thus the use of in vivo approaches is inevitable.
To study breast cancer progression, different experimental methods have been developed. The most widely used model is the subcutaneous injection of breast cancer cells into mice5. In this experimental setup, the investigator may introduce a wide range of alterations to a cell line of choice in vitro (i.e. upregulation, downregulation of proteins) and inject the cells under the skin. Although this method is straightforward and the injection process is simple without any need to perform surgery on the mice, the site at which the tumor is injected does not represent the local mammary tumor environment and the absence of this environment may result in breast cancer development that differs from that observed in human pathology. Secondly, genetically engineered mice are used frequently as an in vivo tool to study breast cancer progression. In this model, oncogene (i.e. PyMT, Neu) expression is driven by a mammary tissue specific promoter leading to the formation of spontaneous breast tumor s. This experimental setup is useful to study the treatment aspect of the disease by injecting drugs or antibodies while checking tumor size in time3. However, breeding these mice with other mouse strains deficient or mutated in a gene of interest might also give insights into the role of different proteins in breast tumor growth24. The downside of this model is that it is prone to variation in tumor size and number. Moreover, the level of transgene expression depends on the integration site in the genome and can change from one mouse strain to another4. In this model, the expression of the transgene can be achieved by all the cells with epithelial origin whereas in human disease, only a subpopulation of cells express the oncogene or downregulate the tumor suppressor levels26. To study metastasis, breast cancer cells may also be injected intravenously (a model termed experimental metastasis)25. However, this approach only recapitulates the metastatic process partially; it circumvents the requirement for tumor cells to invade and intravasate, and starts from the point at which tumor cells are readily present in the circulation.
In our work, we use an orthotopic injection model to study the involvement of genes of interest in breast cancer progression13. We overexpress the protein in human breast cancer cells and inject them into the mammary fat pad of NOD/SCID gamma (NSG) mice. This method is advantageous in many ways: it allows very rapid and diverse genetic changes in the injected cell line, it covers the entire process of breast cancer progression from primary tumor growth to metastasis at pathologically relevant sites, and it also provides a good experimental model for studying the impact of therapeutic treatments at early or late stages of the disease. In addition, using this model one can investigate the role of stromal versus cancer cell-derived proteins in disease progression by using genetically modified mice or cells. Although subcutaneous injections are easier to perform, orthotopic models give rise to a more tumorigenic and more metastatic cancer cell population. Thus, results obtained by means of the subcutaneous injections might be either false-negative or false-positive6,17 encouraging the use of orthotopic models to study the tumor growth.
Animal experiments were approved by the animal welfare committee of the Leiden University Medical Center(LUMC).
1. Preparation of Cells, Instruments and Mice
2. Orthotopic Injection
3. Harvesting Organs for Analysis
Successful application of the “orthotopic breast cancer model” is based on proper injection of cells into the mammary fat pad. Experimental errors such as imprecise inoculation of cells or leakage might lead to variations in tumor size or even the absence of a tumor which leads to the formation of a structure looking similar to a mammary fat pad injected with a control buffer (Figure 2A). The growth rate of the tumor is dependent on the nature of the injected cell line and in general, can be observed through the skin of the mice (Figure 2B). Unlike in vitro experiments, the growth rate of the tumor cells may not be constant in time in vivo (Figure 2C). Due to hypoxia and lack of nutrients, necrotic areas may form and these areas will affect the growth rate of the tumor (Figure 2D). In addition, the gene of interest might impact a certain phase of cancer progression (early or late), thus depending on the experimental setup, tumor growth might start fast but slow down at the end or vice versa.
Care should be taken during the removal procedure of the tumor; rigorous handling may affect the structure of the tumor and leads to problems in immunohistochemical analysis. The area around the tumor may display large vessels that arise from vascular remodeling. These vessels play a crucial role in removal of waste products and supply the tumor tissue with nutrients and oxygen thereby facilitating tumor growth (Figure 2B). Formation of neovessels (angiogenesis) can be investigated by staining the tumor for neovessel markers (i.e. CD31, CD34).
Collection of the lungs in Bouin’s solution helps to visualize superficial metastatic foci on the lungs (Figure 3A). The foci can be distinguished from lung tissue by means of the pale colour and are easy to detect18. Metastasis may be expressed as the number of foci formed on the lung surface. However, formation of foci is cell line-dependent; non-aggressive cells give rise to micrometastasis only or no metastasis at all. Micro metastasis can be easily identified with a haematoxylin/ eosin staining on paraffin-embedded lung tissue (Figure 3C).
Figure 1: Materials and Methods. (A) Surgical equipments required for the injection of breast cancer cells into the mammary fat pad. (B) Representative picture showing the exposure of mammary fat pad.
Figure 2: Overview of the orthotopic breast tumor growth in mice. (A) Media control or (B) Human breast cancer cells (MDA-MB-231) are injected into the mammary fat pad of female NSG mouse. Mice were euthanized and pictures were taken. Tumors are indicated by the dashed circle. The arrow indicates the mammary fat pad. (C) Tumor volume was measured with a calliper by using the following formula: Tumor volume = 0.5 x Length x Width x Width. (D) Overall morphology of the tumor is analysed with H&E staining. I stands for infiltrated cells, T indicates tumor cells and N stands for necrotic area. (Scale bar = 200 µm)
Figure 3: Tumor metastasis to lungs. (A) Lungs of mice that were orthotopically injected with tumor cells (MDA-MB-231). Incubation of lungs in Bouin’s solution exposes the metastatic foci on lungs. (B) Lungs from control mice that underwent orthotopic injection of control media. As can be seen clearly, these control lungs do not show macroscopic metastases. (C) H&E staining shows the metastatic region in lung tissue. The insert shows a low magnification overview of the lung tissue containing the metastatic focus. The black dashed rectangle in the insert is represented in the large panel. Tumor cells are indicated by the white dashed line; note the bigger and denser nuclei. (Black scale bar = 100 µm, white scale bar = 20 µm)
Orthotopic injection of breast cancer cells is a powerful model to study all aspects of cancer growth. Implantation of these cells in the mammary fat pad of the mice should be carefully performed in order to prevent variation in tumor growth. Most importantly, injecting the same amount of cells to each mouse is crucial. To do so, one should trypsinize the cells rigorously without affecting viability of the cells. Non-viable cells should be disregarded during the cell counting and reagents (i.e. trypan blue) that can help to discriminate between dead and viable cells may be useful for determining the viable cell number. Formation of clumps of cells should be avoided by pipetting the cells up and down as formation of cell clumps cause problems during cell counting and leads to miscalculation of the cell number. Another important aspect that should be taken into consideration is the volume of the cells themselves. As described in the protocol section, cells are pelleted in order to suspend them in PBS or media. Before adding PBS or media, the volume of the cells may be estimated by comparing the pellet with tubes filled with different volumes of media. Subsequently the cell volume may be subtracted from the intended media volume, according to the following formula:
Volume of media that needs to be added = Calculated volume – Cell volume
Reagents that are used in the protocol may affect the outcome of the experiment; therefore the protocol should be adjusted accordingly depending on the research question. For instance, if the experiment aims to elucidate the role of a membrane protein in tumor progression, trypsinization may result in digestion of the membrane protein and cause artefacts9. If this is a concern, using buffered EDTA solution or scraping the cells is an alternative to detach the cells. As mentioned above, cells may be resuspended in media, PBS or matrigel for injection. Among these, matrigel is a convenient option as matrigel polymerizes in the fat pad, thus minimizing cells leaking out of the fatpad. In addition, engraftment in the presence of matrigel may enhance tumor growth and metastatic potential of certain cell lines such as the breast cancer cell line MDA-MB-4352, human submandibular carcinoma A253, human epidermoid carcinoma Kb and mouse melanoma B16F10 cells7. Please notice that some matrigel preparations contain growth factors that potentially influence the experimental results. However, growth factor-depleted matrigel is available from various suppliers. Additionally, matrigel acts as an extracellular matrix (ECM) and activates integrin subsets. Thus, if the research question involves the role of integrin function in tumor growth, one should use media or PBS as a carrier for breast cancer cells.
In our experimental setup, we injected human breast cancer cells (MDA-MB-231) into the mammary fat pad of NSG mice. The use of immunodeficient mice obviously makes it harder to study the involvement of immunoregulatory genes in cancer development. However, it is important to note that this technique can be also used in mice with intact immune system if the cells that needs to be injected have mouse origin23. In addition, MDA-MB-231 cell line is Estrogen Receptor negative (ER-) therefore, the impact of hormones in breast cancer development is missing. Still, our previous work showed that this technique is also feasible for ER+ breast cancer cells such as MCF-7 13. Papers utilizing this method to study tumor growth of commonly used breast cancer cell lines are listed below:
The procedure itself contains some critical steps as well. Unlike subcutaneous injections, orthotopic injections involve surgical procedures on mice. Hence, surgical tools should be cleaned well and autoclaved. Of note, implantation of human cells in mammary fat pads requires the use of immunodeficient mice (e.g., NOD/SCID). Therefore injections should preferably be carried out in a biological safety cabinet, using sterile instruments. Moreover, during the injection, the needle should be kept at the right angle with the needle opening facing upwards. Holding the needle in this position reduces leakage and in this manner successful injection can be verified by observing swelling of the mammary fat pad. In addition, when performing surgery, it is crucial to make an incision some distance away from the mammary fat pad in order to avoid interference of the wound healing process with tumor growth. However, the incision should not be made too distant from the mammary fat pad either, as exposing the mammary fat pad might be difficult.
Following the procedure, the animals should be checked regularly. Due to the surgery and exposure to the anaesthetic, mice may experience substantial discomfort or even die. Thus, the first week after the procedure is critical and mice should be monitored carefully. Depending on the growth rate of the implanted cells, tumor volume can be measured up to 4 times a week. The injected cells can also be tagged with a fluorescent protein or luciferase, enabling tracking of primary and metastatic tumor cells, using a light-sensitive camera. Tumors should never be allowed to reach extremely large sizes as ulcerations may occur that damage the tumor tissue. This may hamper proper immunohistochemical analyses of the tumor tissue. Once the tumor is harvested, one might consider mincing the tumor and culturing the dispersed tumor cells to create a new breast cancer cell line to investigate differences between parental and mammay fat pad passed (mfp) cell lines11.
In conclusion, the orthotopic breast cancer implantation that we outlined in this paper is a very useful tool in order to study the cancer related processes. One can manipulate the genome of the injected cells by either upregulating or downregulating the gene of interest and check its effect on primary tumor growth, angiogenesis or metastasis. This approach is helpful to study proto-oncogenes, tumor supressors or genes that are involved in EMT. In addition, the cell lines can be injected to genetically modified mice to examine the effect of stromal compartment in cancer progression. We strongly encourage the use of the orthotopic injection technique over aforementioned breast cancer models due to its high recapitulation of pathophysiological process.
The authors have nothing to disclose.
The authors would like to acknowledge the Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research (NWO, grant 17.106.329)
Name of material/equipment | Company | Catalog number | Comments/Description |
Bouin's solution | Sigma-Aldrich | HT10132 | Used for investigating the metastasis on lungs |
Formalin solution | Sigma-Aldrich | HT501128 | Used to fix the tissues |
Matrigel, growth factor reduced | Corning | 356230 | Cells can be resuspended in matrigel for injection |
Mosquito forceps | Fine Science Tools | 13008-12 | Used for stiching |
Angled forceps | Electron microscopy sciences | 72991-4c | These make the exposure of mammary fat pad easier |
Scissors | B Braun Medicals | BC056R | Used to cut open the mice |
Straight forceps | B Braun Medicals | BD025R | This is used to open up the skin to expose mammary fat pad |
NOD scid gamma mice | Charles River | 005557 | Experimental animal used for experiment |
MDA-MB-231 | Sigma-Aldrich | 92020424 | Experimental cells used for injections |
Oculentum simplex | Teva Pharmachemie | Opthalmic ointment used to prevent drying out of eyes | |
Betadine | Fischer Scientific | 19-898-859 | Ionophore, used to disinfect the surgical area |
Xylazin/Ketamine | Sigma-Aldrich | X1251, K2753 | Use injected anesthesia as 10mg/kg and 100mg/kg body weight respectively |
Temgesic | Schering-Plough | Use the painkiller as 0,05-0,1mg/kg body weight | |
DMEM | Life sciences | 11995 | For trypsin neutralization,use media with serum(FBS:media 1:10 volume); for injection, use media with no serum |
Buffered sodium citrate | Aniara | A12-8480-10 | Use the volume ratio as citrate:blood; 1:9 |